Romania’s Women’s chess player No 1, IM Irina Bulmaga, decided not to be silent about FIDE’s decisions in Women’s chess related to Ukrainian and Russian players’ treatment in official FIDE tournaments. Bulmaga published a post on her blog website under the title “Silence, Hypocrisy and Disgust“, sharing her thoughts about the situation in women’s chess, the war between Russia and Ukraine, FIDE and top women players.
“Today’s post will be about something which has been bothering me for quite a while already. I have been trying to convince myself that I shouldn’t write it, that it’s not my business, that I’ll possibly lose opportunities and invitations to tournaments because of it, but I simply can’t keep silencing this voice inside my head. It is about the situation in women’s chess, the war between Russia and Ukraine, FIDE and top women players.“, starts Irina.
She further on speaks about the participation of women’s world top chess players (World #4 Aleksandra Goryachkina, World #6 Kateryna Lagno and World #21 Bibisara Assaubayeva) in Russian chess tournaments that looked very much like war propaganda events and which included Sergey Karjakin who is publicly supporting Russian invasion on Ukraine.
“I am not sure what was the message they wanted to send to their fans by participating there, getting photographed smiling next to Sergey Karjakin and shaking hands with him. What I understood was that they endorse in one way or another Karjakin’s activity. It shocked me and the more I thought on it- the more it kept upsetting me.“, writes Irina, adding that she expected the same reaction from colleagues, which she found, but only in private conversations. However, the biggest shock came from FIDE which remained silent about the Russian tournaments and had no actions against its participants: “I was utterly surprised when FIDE (the International Chess Federation) not only allowed those players to participate in official FIDE events like the World Rapid & Blitz Championships and the Women’s FIDE Grand Prix and the FIDE Women’s Candidates but also promoted those players as personalities and models for the youngsters to look up to“.
She reminds that the Ukrainian Muzychuk sisters withdrew from the FIDE Women’s Grand Prix Tournaments and that even the last leg of the FIDE Women’s Grand Prix suffered a last-minute change of location (from Poland to Cyprus) to accommodate Russian players who participated in the “Karjakin tournaments”.
“My conclusion was that FIDE has no problem with any of the upper mentioned facts. […] Sport is out of politics.” That’s the main argument which Russian sportsmen, officials and fans use when some countries deny the participation of Russian athletes in their events. I can see why one would say that. If that is the case, how participating in tournaments organized by war instigators and smiling alongside them, shaking hands with them is in any way “out of politics”? Perhaps the FIDE officials have an answer for that too.
As for me, I am disgusted every time I read any news about those players, about FIDE promoting their images as those of great personalities and sportspeople and last, but not least, I am disgusted by the silence of most of my colleagues and about my being silent about it up until now.“, concludes Bulmaga.
The complete text “Silence, Hypocrisy and Disgust” by IM Irina Bulmaga can be found on her blog and down below:
Silence, Hypocrisy and Disgust
Today’s post will be about something which has been bothering me for quite a while already. I have been trying to convince myself that I shouldn’t write it, that it’s not my business, that I’ll possibly lose opportunities and invitations to tournaments because of it, but I simply can’t keep silencing this voice inside my head.
It is about the situation in women’s chess, the war between Russia and Ukraine, FIDE and top women players.
To start with the beginning, I have been thinking a lot on which is my position towards players from Russia competing on the international arena since the war between Russia and Ukraine has begun and I have come to the conclusion that as long as they are playing under a neutral flag- I don’t have a problem with that. Some say that there should be a sort of anti-war declaration signed by them but my views are not as polarized because I’ve realized that there might be situations where it can be dangerous for one’s life, their families or loved ones and not everyone is ready to take these risks. I have tried to imagine myself in this situation and I’ve understood that there might be circumstances under which I might have also stayed silent.
However, in my view, there is a big difference between staying silent and participating in tournaments organized by recognized war instigators (to put it mildly) like Sergey Karjakin. These tournaments looked very much like war propaganda events and it saddened me a lot to see players whom I previously respected or even admired participating there. To my knowledge, there where two such tournaments which were covered extensively by the Russian media and which makes it very easy to access information and photos from these events just by entering some key words in any searching engine. For example, here is a link to a press release from the official site of one of the events: https://chessstars.ru/press-release .
Here, I will speak only about the women players who participated there. They are: World #4 Aleksandra Goryachkina, World #6 Kateryna Lagno- both from Russia and World #21 Bibisara Assaubayeva from Kazakhstan- all very strong and accomplished chess players who are well known in the chess world.
I am not sure what was the message they wanted to send to their fans by participating there, getting photographed smiling next to Sergey Karjakin and shaking hands with him. What I understood was that they endorse in one way or another Karjakin’s activity. It shocked me and the more I thought on it- the more it kept upsetting me.
I expected the same reaction from most of my colleagues and they indeed felt the same way when we discussed it privately.
Like it or not- it is the right of each individual to choose for themselves and it looked to me like those players did.
However, I was utterly surprised when FIDE (the International Chess Federation) not only allowed those players to participate in official FIDE events like the World Rapid & Blitz Championships and the Women’s FIDE Grand Prix and the FIDE Women’s Candidates but also promoted those players as personalities and models for the youngsters to look up to.
Later, the Ukrainian Muzychuk sisters withdrew from the FIDE Women’s Grand Prix tournaments so that the same players could play and even the location of the last leg of the FIDE Women’s Grand Prix was changed last minute from Poland to Cyprus in order to accommodate the same players who participated in the “Karjakin tournaments”.
What conclusion should these things make one draw?
My conclusion was that FIDE has no problem with any of the upper mentioned facts. Is it ignorance or hypocrisy or something else? Every official in FIDE who had any involvement in these decisions knows better.
“Sport is out of politics.” That’s the main argument which Russian sportsmen, officials and fans use when some countries deny the participation of Russian athletes in their events. I can see why one would say that. If that is the case, how participating in tournaments organized by war instigators and smiling alongside them, shaking hands with them is in any way “out of politics”? Perhaps the FIDE officials have an answer for that too.
Photo of the “Chess Stars 2022” participants, held in Moscow- 29 Sept -5 Oct 2022
As for me, I am disgusted every time I read any news about those players, about FIDE promoting their images as those of great personalities and sportspeople and last, but not least, I am disgusted by the silence of most of my colleagues and about my being silent about it up until now.
I believe that by ignoring all of these- we are a part of it too, and honestly- I don’t like what I see in the mirror after all these months of silence.
For those of you who feel the same way- is this really the community you want to be a part of?
What would be the solution? I am not a lawyer- I expected FIDE to have a solution by now and I am deeply disheartened that it’s not the case.
I want to continue playing and promoting chess but it has become very difficult to do so when the situation is the one I’ve described. I have a hard time finding reasons to keep being a part of FIDE and the chess world under these circumstances. What about you?
Do you think that what FIDE is doing is right?
